When it comes to cheese, American cheese and cheddar are two popular choices that often find their way into our sandwiches, burgers, and various recipes. While both cheeses may appear similar, they differ significantly in terms of their nutritional profiles, production methods, and health implications. This article delves into the nutritional differences between American cheese and cheddar, helping you make informed choices for your diet.

Key takeaways

• American cheese tends to have a higher fat content and is more processed, while cheddar cheese is made naturally and offers a better nutritional profile.
• Cheddar cheese is richer in protein and essential nutrients like calcium, making it a healthier option compared to American cheese.
• American cheese contains higher levels of certain vitamins like vitamin B12 and vitamin E, but it also has a significantly higher sodium content.
• Both cheeses are high in calories and should be consumed in moderation, but cheddar provides more nutritional benefits per serving.
• Use the free January app to see calorie and macro information, as well as how both cheddar and American cheese would affect your blood sugar

American cheese vs Cheddar

Both American cheese and cheddar are widely consumed, yet they possess distinct characteristics that set them apart.

What is American cheese?

American cheese is a processed cheese product made from a blend of milk, milk fats, and solids, with other fats and whey protein concentrates. It is known for its smooth, creamy texture and excellent melting properties, making it a favorite for grilled cheese sandwiches and burgers.

What is cheddar cheese?

Cheddar cheese is a natural cheese made from cow's milk. Traditionally, cheddar was made using raw milk and had a natural aging process that contributed to its distinctive flavor and texture. It became trendy in the United Kingdom and later spread to other parts of the world, including the United States.

Key differences in production

• Ingredients: American cheese often contains additional ingredients like emulsifiers and preservatives, while cheddar is made from 100% cow's milk.
• Aging: Cheddar undergoes an aging process that can range from a few months to several years, enhancing its flavor and texture. American cheese does not age in the same way.
• Texture and Melting: American cheese has a smooth, creamy texture and melts evenly, making it ideal for certain culinary applications. Cheddar, especially aged varieties, has a more crumbly texture and a robust flavor.

Macronutrient breakdown: American cheese vs cheddar

When it comes to choosing between American cheese and cheddar, understanding their macronutrient profiles can help you make an informed decision. Both cheeses have the same average serving size, equal to 1oz or 28.35g, but their nutritional content varies significantly. A super easy way to see the nutritional differences in foods is by using the free January app. As you can see in the above image, the app shows the nutritional profile of each, and also the predicted blood sugar impact. In both cases, the impact is very minimal, meaning if you're concerned about blood sugar management — as we all should be, whether we're healthy or not — this app is ideal to give you a full picture of what you're putting in your body. The January app is completely free to download and use. You can even take a photo of your meal and instantly you'll find the macro information and the predicted glucose response. Whether at a restaurant, in the grocery store. or rummaging around the pantry, we always keep the January app on hand to help us make the best choices for our health goals.

You can download the January app for free here.

Caloric content

American cheese is lower in calories compared to cheddar. One slice of American cheese contains around 65 calories, while cheddar cheese has approximately 114 calories per slice. This difference can be crucial for those monitoring their caloric intake. Again, just look up the food in the January app, or scan the cheese's barcode on the packet, and you'll get the entire nutritional profile.

Protein levels

Cheddar cheese offers a better nutritional profile with natural ingredients and a range of beneficial nutrients. It contains about 6 grams of protein per slice, whereas American cheese has only 3 grams. Protein is essential for muscle repair and growth, making cheddar a more protein-rich option.

Fat composition

While American cheese tends to have higher fat content and is more processed, cheddar cheese is relatively denser in nutrients. Both cheeses contain around 9 grams of fat per slice, but the type of fat varies. Cheddar has more monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats, which are considered healthier. However, both cheeses have equal amounts of saturated fat, which should be consumed in moderation.

Portion sizes and moderation are key when incorporating either cheese into a balanced diet. Opting for sandwich alternatives like cheese, spreads, and deconstructed options can minimize blood sugar spikes. Focus on healthy ingredients and avoid added sugars.

Vitamin and mineral comparison

Calcium and phosphorus

When it comes to calcium and phosphorus, both American cheese and cheddar are excellent sources. However, American cheese contains over four times more iron and also has higher levels of calcium, potassium, phosphorus, copper, manganese, and choline. Cheddar, on the other hand, is richer in zinc and selenium.

If you're looking to boost your calcium intake, American cheese might be the better option.

Vitamin B complex

Both types of cheese offer a good range of B vitamins, but they are equal in Vitamin B5. This makes them both beneficial for energy metabolism and maintaining healthy skin and nerves.

Sodium content

One of the most significant differences between these two cheeses is their sodium content. Cheddar contains significantly less sodium, with 2.5 times less sodium than American cheese. This makes cheddar a better choice for those who are watching their sodium intake.

• American cheese: Higher in calcium, potassium, phosphorus, copper, manganese, and choline
• Cheddar: Higher in zinc and selenium, lower in sodium

Health implications of consuming American cheese and cheddar

Impact on heart health

American cheese is high in saturated fat and sodium, both of which may increase the risk of high blood pressure and heart disease. Cheddar cheese, while also containing saturated fat, generally has a better nutritional profile with more natural ingredients. Moderation is key when consuming either type of cheese to maintain heart health.

Weight management

When it comes to weight management, portion control is crucial. Both American cheese and cheddar are calorie-dense, so it's easy to consume more calories than intended. Opting for smaller portions can help you enjoy these cheeses without derailing your weight management goals.

Digestive health

Cheddar cheese is often easier to digest compared to American cheese, which is more processed. The natural aging process of cheddar can make it a better option for those with lactose sensitivity. However, both types of cheese should be consumed in moderation to avoid digestive issues.

Choosing the right cheese for your diet

Dietary preferences

When it comes to choosing between American cheese and cheddar, your dietary preferences play a significant role. If you're following a low-fat diet, you might want to opt for cheddar cheese, which generally has a better nutritional profile compared to American cheese. On the other hand, if you're looking for a cheese that melts easily and adds a creamy texture to your dishes, American cheese could be your go-to.

Portion control

A good rule of thumb is to stick to a serving size of about one ounce, which is roughly the size of a pair of dice. Remember, moderation is key when incorporating cheese into your diet. Overindulgence can lead to unwanted health issues, so always be mindful of your portions.

Flavor profiles and culinary uses

Taste differences

American cheese and cheddar have distinct flavor profiles that cater to different palates. American cheese is known for its mild, creamy taste, making it a favorite in fast-food establishments and for those who prefer a subtler cheese flavor. On the other hand, cheddar cheese offers a more robust and complex flavor, which can range from mild to extra sharp depending on its aging process. This makes cheddar a versatile option for various culinary applications.

Cooking applications

American cheese is incredibly versatile due to its smooth, creamy texture that melts easily. This cheese is most popularly used for burgers, grilled cheese sandwiches, macaroni and cheese, and other comfort foods where creamy, melty cheese is desired. Cheddar cheese, with its rich flavor, is often used in cooking and baking to add depth and complexity to recipes. It’s a delightful addition to sandwiches, omelets, and cheese platters.

While American cheese is prevalent in fast food and sandwiches, cheddar cheese is versatile in various culinary uses, from snacking to cooking and pairing it with other ingredients.

Pairing suggestions

When it comes to pairing, American cheese works well with simple, hearty dishes. Think cheeseburgers, grilled cheese sandwiches, and cheese melts. Cheddar cheese, however, pairs excellently with a broader range of foods. For a classic combination, try cheddar with apples or pears. It also complements nuts, whole-grain crackers, and even dark chocolate. The versatility of cheddar makes it a favorite for cheese boards and gourmet recipes alike.

Conclusion

American cheese vs cheddar. When it comes to choosing between American cheese and cheddar, it ultimately depends on your nutritional priorities and taste preferences. American cheese tends to have a higher fat content and is more processed, while cheddar offers a better nutritional profile with natural ingredients and a range of beneficial nutrients. Cheddar also provides a broader selection of varieties and aging options, allowing for different flavor intensities and complexities. However, both cheeses should be consumed in moderation as part of a balanced diet. Whether you prefer the convenience and 'meltability' of American cheese or the rich, complex flavors of cheddar, understanding their nutritional differences can help you make an informed choice.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main differences between American cheese and cheddar cheese?

American cheese tends to have a higher fat content and is more processed, while cheddar cheese provides a better nutritional profile and is made naturally. Cheddar cheese also offers a broader selection of varieties and aging options, allowing for different flavor intensities and complexities.

Is American cheese healthier than cheddar cheese?

While American cheese tends to have higher fat content and is more processed, cheddar cheese offers a better nutritional profile with natural ingredients and a range of beneficial nutrients. However, it’s imperative to consider portion sizes and moderation for both cheeses in a balanced diet.

What is the caloric content of American cheese compared to cheddar cheese?

A 100g serving of American cheese contains 371 calories, while the same serving size of cheddar provides 404 calories. Both cheeses are high-calorie foods, but cheddar is slightly higher in calories.

Which cheese has more protein, American or cheddar?

Cheddar cheese is richer in protein compared to American cheese. For every 100g serving, cheddar provides 5g more protein than American cheese.

How do the vitamin contents of American cheese and cheddar cheese compare?

American cheese contains higher levels of vitamin B12, vitamin B3, and vitamin E. Both cheddar and American cheese contain similar amounts of vitamin D, vitamin B5, and vitamin K, and neither contains vitamin C.

Is there a significant difference in sodium content between American cheese and cheddar cheese?

Yes, there is a significant difference in sodium content. American cheese has 1,660 milligrams of sodium per 100 grams, while cheddar has only 679 milligrams. This makes American cheese much higher in sodium compared to cheddar.

‍