Beyond its rich aroma and robust flavor, coffee can significantly affect blood sugar levels and insulin needs. This article answers the question: "Does coffee raise blood sugar?"

Key takeaways

• Coffee can influence blood sugar levels, particularly for people with Type 1 Diabetes (T1D).
• Adding sugar or creamer to coffee can increase blood sugar levels, making it important to choose drinks without added sugar.
• Plain coffee does not seem to directly increase blood sugar levels, but caffeine can impair insulin sensitivity.
• Using the January app to see your predicted blood sugar spike prior to consuming coffee can help determine if caffeine has an impact on you personally.
• Opting for black coffee or using natural sweeteners can be healthier choices for blood sugar control.

Does coffee raise blood sugar levels?

While plain coffee generally doesn't seem to directly increase blood sugar levels, some research does suggest it could impair insulin sensitivity. How you take your coffee matters, too. Sweeteners and high-calorie creamers can raise your blood sugar levels, potentially even significantly. Low-sugar dairy alternatives, like unsweetened almond milk, can help minimize the impact on blood sugar. When it comes to alternative sweeteners, be thoughtful — many can still raise blood sugar despite the claims on the packaging. We recommend using the free January app to look up any food or drink item and see how your blood sugar will respond without ever taking a bite or sip. The app will also offer healthier alternatives for you to consider in order to keep your glucose curve as stable as possible.

Let's look at a few examples in the January app below. If you look at the far left, you'll notice there's no notable spike when looking at black coffee. However, the middle image shows the difference if you add a large serving of milk. While the spike is still in range, the impact is clear. In the far right image, we compare a vanilla latte against an almond milk latte (the vanilla latte is the black line and the almond milk latte is the green). You can see the almond milk latte will spike your blood sugar considerably less.

If you'd like to try this for yourself to how you personally would respond, you can download the January app here. It's completely free to download and use.

The science behind coffee and blood sugar levels

Research findings

Research on coffee and blood sugar levels has produced mixed results. Some studies suggest that caffeine can impair insulin sensitivity, leading to higher blood sugar levels. However, other research indicates that coffee consumption is linked to a lower risk of developing type 2 diabetes. The impact of coffee on blood sugar can vary significantly from person to person.

Individual variations

Individual responses to coffee can differ widely. Factors such as genetics, overall health, and even the time of day can influence how coffee affects your blood sugar. For some, caffeine increases dopamine levels, enhancing mood and concentration, while for others, it may cause blood sugar spikes. The long-term effects of coffee on blood sugar levels are still being studied, too. While some research points to potential benefits, such as a lower risk of type 2 diabetes, other studies highlight the need for caution, especially for those with existing blood sugar management issues.

Caffeine sensitivity and blood sugar spikes

Why some people are more sensitive

Caffeine, the primary stimulant in coffee, can temporarily raise blood sugar levels by triggering the release of stress hormones that prompt the liver to release stored glucose into the bloodstream. The result? A short-term spike in blood sugar levels. Some people's blood sugar is extra-sensitive to caffeine, leading to more pronounced spikes. This sensitivity can vary widely among individuals, making it essential to understand your own body's response.

Testing your own sensitivity

To determine how caffeine affects your blood sugar, consider conducting a simple test:

1. Measure your blood sugar levels before consuming coffee.
2. Drink a cup of coffee without any additives.
3. Measure your blood sugar levels at intervals of 30 minutes, 1 hour, and 2 hours after consumption.
4. Record your findings and look for patterns.

This self-testing can help you understand if caffeine is a significant factor in your blood sugar management.

Adjusting your coffee habits

If you find that caffeine significantly impacts your blood sugar, you may need to adjust your coffee habits. Here are some tips:

• Opt for decaffeinated coffee to reduce caffeine intake.
• Limit the number of cups you drink per day.
• Avoid drinking coffee on an empty stomach to minimize spikes.

Managing stress and eating more foods high in fiber and probiotics may help lower blood sugar levels naturally. Adjusting your coffee habits is just one part of a comprehensive approach to blood sugar management.

Healthier coffee choices for blood sugar control

Opting for black coffee

The best way to drink coffee without impacting your blood sugar is to opt for black coffee, or with a natural alternative sweetener. Black coffee has zero carbs and won't raise your blood sugar levels. If you find black coffee too bitter, try adding a splash of unsweetened almond milk or a sprinkle of cinnamon for flavor without the sugar spike.

Using natural sweeteners

When it comes to sweetening your coffee, be thoughtful. Many artificial sweeteners can still raise blood sugar despite the claims on the packaging. Opt for natural sweeteners like stevia or monk fruit, which are less likely to affect your blood sugar levels. Remember, moderation is key.

Exploring decaffeinated options

Switching to decaffeinated coffee can be a safer bet for those sensitive to caffeine. Decaf coffee provides the same rich flavor without the caffeine, which can sometimes cause blood sugar spikes. It's a great way to enjoy your favorite beverage without the added worry.

Staying informed about new research

Stay updated on the latest research findings related to coffee and blood sugar management. New studies are constantly emerging, and staying informed can help you make better choices. Green tea, for exmaple, may reduce T2D risk, improve weight loss. Research on benefits promising but more studies needed. Always consult with healthcare professionals to understand how new information might apply to your individual situation.

Conclusion

Navigating the relationship between coffee and blood sugar can be a bit of a balancing act, especially for those with diabetes. While plain black coffee doesn't seem to directly raise blood sugar levels, the caffeine it contains can affect insulin sensitivity and potentially cause short-term spikes in blood sugar. Additives like sugar and creamer can further complicate matters by increasing blood sugar levels. The best approach is to monitor your body's response to coffee and consult with your healthcare provider to determine what works best for you. Whether you choose to stick with your daily cup of joe or switch to decaf, being mindful of how coffee affects your blood sugar is key to maintaining your health.

Frequently asked questions

Does coffee raise blood sugar levels?

Plain coffee does not seem to directly increase levels of blood sugar or blood glucose. However, the caffeine in coffee could impair insulin sensitivity, which may affect blood sugar levels.

How does caffeine affect blood sugar?

Caffeine can temporarily raise blood sugar levels by triggering the release of stress hormones that prompt the liver to release stored glucose into the bloodstream. This can result in a short-term spike in blood sugar levels.

Are there any additives in coffee that can raise blood sugar levels?

Yes, adding sugar, creamer, or certain artificial sweeteners to coffee can increase blood sugar levels. It is recommended to choose drinks without added sugar or use natural sweeteners.

Can people with diabetes drink coffee?

Yes, people with diabetes can drink coffee, but they should monitor how it affects their blood sugar levels. Opting for black coffee or using natural sweeteners is generally more healthful.

Is decaffeinated coffee a better option for people with diabetes?

Some doctors believe that switching to decaffeinated coffee is a safer option for people with diabetes as it eliminates the potential impact of caffeine on blood sugar levels.

How can I test if coffee affects my blood sugar?

To test if coffee affects your blood sugar, download the free-to-use January app and simply search for your choice of coffee — from Starbucks to Peets, to your favorite grocery store blend. The January app will show your predicted glucose curve so you can make the smartest choice possible. Download the January app here.

‍